Productivity, checked · Part 5 of 8
Energy: the machine that runs the line
In September 1915 the Minister of Munitions set up a committee to look at something nobody had much time for in wartime: fatigue. The factories were running long shifts, often seven days a week. The committee's most urgent concern was Sunday labour. Its view was that workers who never stopped did not produce more shells. They just looked more tired producing them.
A century later, an economist went back to the output records of those factories, and the committee turned out to be right. That is the theme of this part. The previous three stations were about what goes onto the production line, how it moves, and how much attention it gets. This one is about the machine itself, which in knowledge work is a person. Is the machine maintained, or is it being run into the ground and called dedication?
The books are full of advice here, and this is where the pattern from the introduction shows most clearly. The mechanisms mostly hold. The sizes, and a few famous findings, do not.
Sleep: the debt you don't feel
The best evidence on sleep and work comes from a small, careful lab study. Van Dongen and colleagues (2003) put 48 adults aged 21 to 38 on 4, 6 or 8 hours in bed for 14 days, and compared them with people kept awake for three nights. On 4 and 6 hours, cognitive deficits grew steadily, night after night. After two weeks, the 6-hour group was performing about as badly as people who had missed up to two full nights of sleep. The unsettling part was that their sleepiness ratings barely moved. They felt slightly tired. They were badly impaired.
That gap between feeling and performance is the core of the problem. Short sleep is a debt that doesn't show up on your own statement. If you judge whether you're coping by how you feel, you will conclude that you are coping.
A related finding is often quoted: after 17 to 19 hours awake, people in one study performed on some tests like someone at 0.05% blood alcohol (Williamson & Feyer 2000, 39 people) ~70 %. It is a vivid comparison, with caveats. Long hours awake also mean late night, the body's natural low, and equal test scores are not equal crash risk.
Naps help, within limits. A meta-analysis of 11 studies found that a short nap improved cognitive performance, mostly alertness, for up to about two hours (Dutheil et al. 2021) ~85 %. Almost all of this is lab work, and there's little direct evidence on whether naps can repay a chronic debt. A nap is a patch, not a repair.
This is where Matthew Walker's Why We Sleep comes in, and it deserves a fair hearing in both directions. Its core message, that chronic short sleep damages thinking and people don't notice, rests on exactly the kind of evidence above. Its headline numbers are another matter. The book says that routinely sleeping less than six or seven hours more than doubles your cancer risk; it gives no source, and a meta-analysis of 65 studies and about 1.55 million people found no link at all (Chen et al. 2018) ~5 %. It says the WHO declared a sleep-loss epidemic; the WHO made no such declaration, and Walker later said he had misremembered. It says sleep time has fallen sharply over 50 years; a review of 168 studies of objectively measured sleep from 1960 to 2013 found no decline (Youngstedt et al. 2016) ~15 %. It even reproduces a chart with the one inconvenient bar removed. The book is right that sleep matters. It is wrong about much of the evidence it uses to make you frightened of not sleeping.
Caffeine and alcohol: the two tools that lie to you
The two most common ways people manage their energy share a property: both work on how you feel, not on what's happening.
Caffeine's half-life in a typical adult is about five to six hours, with wide variation. In one small study (Drake et al. 2013, 12 people, 400 mg), caffeine taken even six hours before bed cut objectively measured sleep by more than an hour, and the participants didn't notice ~85 %. The afternoon coffee feels harmless because, subjectively, it is.
Alcohol does the reverse trick. It feels like a sleep aid and works as a sedative. A meta-analysis of 27 studies found that REM sleep is disrupted from about two standard drinks, and more with each one; falling asleep faster happened only at high doses (Gardiner et al. 2025) ~85 %. The glass of wine that "helps you unwind" helps you fall unconscious, which is not the same thing.
Both effects fit the Van Dongen pattern. The instrument you'd use to check your energy, your own sense of it, is the one being tampered with.
Hours: where the curve bends
Back to the munition factories. John Pencavel (2014) analysed output and hours for British munition workers, mostly women, between 1914 and 1918. Below about 49 hours a week, output rose in proportion to hours. Above that it flattened, peaking at about 63 hours. A 70-hour week produced about the same output as a 56-hour week: fourteen extra hours, nothing to show for them. Weeks without a rest day had about 10% lower output for the same hours. The Sunday committee had a point ~85 %.
The obvious caveat is that turning shells on a lathe is not writing a strategy memo. The shape of the curve, rising and then flattening, probably transfers to other work. The thresholds may not (~50%).
The modern experiment runs the other way: fewer hours, not more. A study of four-day-week trials covering 141 organisations and 2,896 employees in six countries, with about five fewer hours a week, found that burnout and job satisfaction improved most, and that the gains largely held after 12 months (Fan, Schor et al. 2025). In the UK pilot of 2022, 56 of the 61 companies kept the arrangement. The weakness is in the design. The companies chose to take part, nobody was randomised, the results are self-reported, and output was barely measured; revenue stayed roughly flat. That fewer hours means less burnout is reasonably supported ~70 %. That it costs no output is plausible but unproven (~50%).
Breaks and switching off
Short breaks are the most common energy advice and the most modest. A meta-analysis of micro-breaks of ten minutes or less (Albulescu et al. 2022, 22 samples, 2,335 people) found that they raised vigour and reduced fatigue by a small-to-moderate amount (d = .36 and .35). Performance barely moved (d = .16, not significant), and the gains showed up on less demanding tasks. Longer breaks helped more ~85 %. So a coffee-machine break makes you feel better, which is worth having, but don't expect it to rescue a hard afternoon.
What happens after work matters more. A meta-analysis of 91 samples and over 38,000 employees found that people who mentally detach from work in their free time report less exhaustion, better sleep and higher life satisfaction, and do somewhat better on their tasks (Wendsche & Lohmann-Haislah 2017) ~70 %. Two caveats. The data are mostly correlational, so healthier people may simply find it easier to switch off. And detachment went with slightly lower creativity and helpfulness, perhaps because the people who keep thinking about work are also the ones who solve problems in the shower and answer colleagues' questions in the evening.
Holidays follow the same logic and fade fast. One meta-analysis found a clear boost to wellbeing from a vacation (d = .43) that faded after return; a later one, with 13 studies, found no difference from baseline after the first week back (de Bloom et al. 2009). Longer leave seems to do more: in one study of 129 academics on sabbatical compared with 129 matched colleagues, wellbeing rose during the leave (Davidson et al. 2010).
This is the territory of Cal Newport's Slow Productivity, which argues for a "natural pace": longer timelines, and work in seasons, with intense phases followed by lighter ones. The evidence above is compatible with it, and the sabbatical study supports part of it. But nobody has tested whether seasonal rhythms beat a steady pace (~50%), and the book's star witnesses, Newton, Austen and other slow geniuses, are anecdotes picked for fit. The book's stronger argument, doing fewer things at once, is queueing math and belongs to Flow.
The willpower tank that wasn't
For about two decades, the most popular explanation of tiredness at work was ego depletion: self-control draws on a limited resource that gets used up during the day, like fuel in a tank. Resist the biscuits in the morning and you'll have less left for the report in the afternoon. A glucose drink was supposed to top the tank up. Daniel Kahneman's Thinking, Fast and Slow presented it as established; Cal Newport's Deep Work built its case for rituals on it.
It did not survive testing. A replication across 23 labs with 2,141 participants found an effect of d = .04, with a confidence interval that included zero (Hagger et al. 2016). A second, designed together with the theory's own proponents, ran in 36 labs with 3,531 participants and found d = .06; the data favoured no effect (Vohs et al. 2021). The glucose story fell with it.
The most famous field illustration went the same way. Judges were said to grant parole about 65% of the time after a food break, falling to near zero just before the next one (Danziger et al. 2011). But cases weren't heard in random order, and simulations show that sensible scheduling of cases can produce most of the pattern (Glöckner 2016) ~30 %.
None of this means people don't get tired. They obviously do, and the sleep and hours data above show it. What failed is the specific model: a single willpower fuel that each act of restraint drains. What replaces it is more useful. People with high self-control mostly don't resist temptation more; they run into it less. In experience-sampling studies of everyday desires, those who scored high on self-control were mainly better at avoiding tempting situations in the first place (Hofmann et al. 2012; Ent, Baumeister & Tice 2015). The practical advice in Deep Work, rituals and routines that don't need to be renegotiated every day, survives. Just not for the reason given. (How to design that environment is the subject of Choose.)
What doesn't work
- The willpower tank. Ego depletion: two multi-lab replications, over 5,600 participants combined, effects near zero (Hagger et al. 2016; Vohs et al. 2021) ~5 %
- Hungry judges as proof of depletion. The parole pattern is largely explained by how cases were ordered (Glöckner 2016) ~30 %
- Short sleep doubles cancer risk. A meta-analysis of 65 studies found no link (Chen et al. 2018) ~5 %
- Hours beyond the bend. In the munition data, 70-hour weeks produced about what 56-hour weeks did (Pencavel 2014) ~85 %
- Micro-breaks as a performance tool. They lift mood and energy, but the effect on demanding work was small and not significant (Albulescu et al. 2022) ~85 %
Try this
- Don't use how you feel to judge your sleep. Fix a bedtime that allows at least seven hours in bed for two weeks, then judge your work, not your mood.
- Move the last coffee earlier. Given a half-life of five to six hours and the Drake result, aim for no caffeine within about six hours of bed, and more if you're sensitive.
- Treat evening alcohol as a sleep cost. From about two drinks, expect worse REM sleep, whatever it feels like.
- Cap the week and keep a full day off. If you're regularly past 50 hours, the extra hours are likely buying very little; a weekly rest day was worth about 10% of output in the munition data.
- End work deliberately. Close the laptop at a set time and stop checking messages, so that the evening is actually off. Use short breaks for energy, not as a fix for overload.
13 claims checked
The evidence behind this article
Every claim above, rated by the chance it holds up against the research. Open one for the sources and their exact words.
- Albulescu, Macsinga, Rusu, Sulea, Bodnaru, Tulbure (2022). "Give me a break!" A systematic review and meta-analysis on the efficacy of micro-breaks for increasing well-being and performance · Meta-analysis
- Chen, Tan, Wei, Li, Lyu, Feng, Wen, Guo, He, Dai, Li (2018). Sleep duration and the risk of cancer: a systematic review and meta-analysis including dose–response relationship · Meta-analysis
- Danziger, Levav, Avnaim-Pesso (2011). Extraneous factors in judicial decisions · Study
- Davidson et al. (2010). Sabbatical leave: Who gains and how much? · Study
- de Bloom et al. (2009). Do we recover from vacation? Meta-analysis of vacation effects on health and well-being · Meta-analysis
- Drake, Roehrs, Shambroom, Roth (2013). Caffeine Effects on Sleep Taken 0, 3, or 6 Hours before Going to Bed · Study
- Dutheil, Danini, Bagheri, Fantini, Pereira, Moustafa, Trousselard, Navel (2021). Effects of a Short Daytime Nap on the Cognitive Performance: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis · Meta-analysis
- Ent, Baumeister, Tice (2015). Trait self-control and the avoidance of temptation · Study
- Fan, Schor, Kelly, Gu (2025). Work time reduction via a 4-day workweek finds improvements in workers’ well-being · Study
- Gardiner, Weakley, Burke, Roach, Sargent, Maniar, Huynh, Miller, Townshend, Halson (2025). The effect of alcohol on subsequent sleep in healthy adults: A systematic review and meta-analysis · Meta-analysis
- Glöckner (2016). The irrational hungry judge effect revisited: Simulations reveal that the magnitude of the effect is overestimated · Study
- Hagger, Chatzisarantis, Alberts, Anggono, Batailler, Birt, Brand, Brandt, Brewer, Bruyneel, Calvillo, Campbell, Cannon, Carlucci, Carruth, Cheung, Crowell, De Ridder, Dewitte, Elson, Evans, Fay, Fennis, Finley, Francis, Heise, Hoemann, Inzlicht, Koole, Koppel, Kroese, Lange, Lau, Lynch, Martijn, Merckelbach, Mills, Michirev, Miyake, Mosser, Muise, Muller, Muzi, Nalis, Nurwanti, Otgaar, Philipp, Primoceri, Rentzsch, Ringos, Schlinkert, Schmeichel, Schoch, Schrama, Schütz, Stamos, Tinghög, Ullrich, vanDellen, Wimbarti, Wolff, Yusainy, Zerhouni, Zwienenberg (2016). A Multilab Preregistered Replication of the Ego-Depletion Effect · Replication
- Hofmann, Baumeister, Förster, Vohs (2012). Everyday temptations: An experience sampling study of desire, conflict, and self-control · Study
- Pencavel (2014). The Productivity of Working Hours · Study
- Van Dongen, Maislin, Mullington, Dinges (2003). The Cumulative Cost of Additional Wakefulness: Dose-Response Effects on Neurobehavioral Functions and Sleep Physiology From Chronic Sleep Restriction and Total Sleep Deprivation · Study
- Vohs, Schmeichel, Lohmann, Gronau, Finley, Ainsworth, Alquist, Baker, Brizi, Bunyi, Butschek, Campbell, Capaldi, Cau, Chambers, Chatzisarantis, Christensen, Clay, Curtis, De Cristofaro, del Rosario, Diel, Doğruol, Doi, Donaldson, Eder, Ersoff, Eyink, Falkenstein, Fennis, Findley, Finkel, Forgea, Friese, Fuglestad, Garcia-Willingham, Geraedts, Gervais, Giacomantonio, Gibson, Gieseler, Gineikiene, Gloger, Gobes, Grande, Hagger, Hartsell, Hermann, Hidding, Hirt, Hodge, Hofmann, Howell, Hutton, Inzlicht, James, Johnson, Johnson, Joyce, Joye, Kaben, Kammrath, Kelly, Kissell, Koole, Krishna, Lam, Lee, Lee, Leighton, Loschelder, Maranges, Masicampo, Mazara, McCarthy, McGregor, Mead, Mendes, Meslot, Michalak, Milyavskaya, Miyake, Moeini-Jazani, Muraven, Nakahara, Patel, Petrocelli, Pollak, Price, Ramsey, Rath, Robertson, Rockwell, Russ, Salvati, Saunders, Scherer, Schütz, Schmitt, Segerstrom, Serenka, Sharpinskyi, Shaw, Sherman, Song, Sosa, Spillane, Stapels, Stinnett, Strawser, Sweeny, Theodore, Tonnu, van Oldenbeuving, vanDellen, Vergara, Walker, Waugh, Weise, Werner, Wheeler, White, Wichman, Wiggins, Wills, Wilson, Wagenmakers, Albarracín (2021). A Multisite Preregistered Paradigmatic Test of the Ego-Depletion Effect · Replication
- Wendsche, Lohmann-Haislah (2017). A Meta-Analysis on Antecedents and Outcomes of Detachment from Work · Meta-analysis
- Williamson, Feyer (2000). Moderate sleep deprivation produces impairments in cognitive and motor performance equivalent to legally prescribed levels of alcohol intoxication · Study
- Youngstedt, Goff, Reynolds, Kripke, Irwin, Bootzin, Khan, Jean-Louis (2016). Has adult sleep duration declined over the last 50+ years? · Meta-analysis