Skip to main content

Productivity, checked · Part 2 of 8

Choose: most decisions are made before the moment

November 18, 2026·11 min read
17 claims checked

At lunchtime in the cafeteria of Massachusetts General Hospital, people reach into the fridges and pick a drink. In 2012 a team of researchers changed what came out of those fridges without asking anyone to try harder. First they put traffic-light labels on everything, and sales of red-labelled drinks, mostly sugary ones, fell 16.5%. Then they rearranged the shelves so that water and healthier items were easier to see and reach. Red drinks fell a further 11.4% and bottled water rose 25.8%, while two comparison cafeterias saw no such shift (Thorndike et al. 2012). Two years later, red drinks were still down, from 26% to 17% of drink sales (Thorndike et al. 2014).

The person at the fridge feels as if they are choosing. Most of the choosing was done earlier, by whoever stocked the shelves. Work is like that too. By Monday morning, the important decisions (which projects you said yes to, what you're aiming for, what happens when the work gets unpleasant) have mostly been made, deliberately or by default. Peter Drucker put the stakes plainly: nothing is so useless as doing with great efficiency what should not be done at all (Drucker 1963).

So the first station asks two things. Am I working on the right things? And is the decision made in advance, rather than at the fridge door?

Specific goals, unless you're still learning

Atomic Habits tells readers to forget about goals and build systems instead, because winners and losers share the same goals. Winners and losers also share alarm clocks. The research on goal-setting disagrees.

Edwin Locke and Gary Latham's summary of the field found that specific, hard goals beat "do your best" by a moderate to large margin (d = .42 to .80), across well over 100 tasks, more than 40,000 participants and at least eight countries (Locke & Latham 2002) (~85%). The caveat is that the summary was written by the theory's founders. The logic is easy to see: "do your best" draws no line to cross, so almost any effort can count as your best.

There is an exception. The effect shrinks as tasks get more complex: d = .41 for the most complex against .77 for the simplest (Wood, Mento & Locke 1987). In an air-traffic-control simulation, an outcome goal actually hurt learning (Kanfer & Ackerman 1989); a learning goal, such as "find three strategies that work", fixed it (Winters & Latham 1996) ~70 %. A nurse in her first week on a new ward doesn't need a target for patients per shift. She needs a target for what to figure out.

Clear's "systems" aren't worthless, though. Much of what he means overlaps with the next tool.

Fantasise, then find the obstacle

Gabriele Oettingen's Rethinking Positive Thinking sums up two decades of her lab's work on imagining success. In one set of studies, graduates who fantasised more about a great job sent out fewer applications, got fewer offers and earned lower salaries two years later (Oettingen & Mayer 2002). Expectations based on experience had the opposite effect ~70 %. The samples were small and come from one lab, but the distinction is useful: confidence helps, while daydreaming feels like progress without being any.

Her fix, mental contrasting, pairs the wish with the main inner obstacle: a habit, a mood, a belief. Add an if-then plan and you get WOOP: wish, outcome, obstacle, plan. A meta-analysis of 21 studies found a small-to-moderate benefit (g = 0.34), possibly inflated by publication bias; versions people ran on their own did worse than ones guided by a researcher (Wang, Wang & Gai 2021) ~70 %.

If-then plans ("if it's 4 pm and the report isn't started, then I close my email and open the draft") are the best-tested part. The figure that went into many books was d = .65, from a 2006 meta-analysis of 94 tests (Gollwitzer & Sheeran 2006). The 2024 update, with 642 tests, found d = .36, and about .15 after correcting for publication bias (Sheeran, Listrom & Gollwitzer 2024) ~85 %. The authors call the effect robust but small. It was larger with strict if-then wording (.43 against .29 for schedule-style plans), high motivation and rehearsal. An if-then plan is cheap rather than powerful, which is a fine thing for a tool to be.

What should the plan target? Piers Steel's meta-analysis of 691 correlations gives an answer (Steel 2007) ~85 %. People put off tasks that are unpleasant (r = .40), and the people who put things off tend to be impulsive (.41), distractible (.45) and low in conscientiousness (−.62). Perfectionism, the most flattering self-diagnosis available, barely registers (−.03). Procrastination also costs performance (r = −.19). The data describe who procrastinates, not what cures it, but they point the plan at the right moment: the unpleasant start and the tempting distraction.

Habits: decide once, then stop deciding

A habit is a decision you no longer have to make. The question is how long the handover takes. In the best-known study, 96 volunteers each picked a new daily behaviour; for the 39 whose data fitted a curve well, it took a median of 66 days to get 95% of the way to automatic, with a range of 18 to 254 days (Lally et al. 2010) ~85 %. The upper end was projected beyond the 84-day study, and automaticity was self-reported. Missing a day or two made no significant difference.

The cafeteria shows the other half: the environment does much of the deciding. In a study of 205 adults reporting 7,827 desires, people high in self-control mostly avoided temptations rather than resisting them (Hofmann et al. 2012), though the data are correlational. Making the good option easier and the bad one harder is well supported in direction; the size varies a lot by setting ~70 %.

Temptation bundling, pairing something you want with something you should do, shows a common pattern. In the first experiment, people who could only listen to gripping audiobooks at the gym went 51% more often, though the effect faded, especially after Thanksgiving (Milkman, Minson & Volpp 2014). A follow-up with 6,792 people raised the chance of a weekly workout by 10–14% (Kirgios et al. 2020). Big in the first small study, smaller but real at scale ~70 %. (The famous "1% better every day" is a separate problem; see Feedback.)

Simple rules beat gut feel

Some decisions come up again and again: whom to hire, which requests to accept, which patient to see first. Here the evidence is about as strong as psychology gets. Across 136 studies, simple statistical rules were about 10% more accurate than expert judgment on average; experts did clearly better in only 6–16% of studies, whatever the task or their experience (Grove et al. 2000).

Hiring is the everyday version. A structured interview, with the same questions for every candidate and each answer scored on a fixed scale, predicts job performance with a validity of about .42; a free-flowing conversation manages about .19 (Sackett et al. 2022) ~85 %. Drucker made the general point: if a problem is generic, solve it once with a rule instead of treating every case as unique (Drucker 1967).

For one-off decisions there is the premortem: before committing, the team imagines the project has failed a year from now and writes down why. In the study behind it, imagining the outcome as already happened raised the number of reasons people found by about 30% (Mitchell, Russo & Pennington 1989). It lets the doubters speak before the money is spent.

Afterwards, judge the decision by how it was made, not only by how it turned out; why that is harder than it sounds is a question for Feedback.

Motivation: rewards, autonomy and passion

Daniel Pink's Drive argues that carrots and sticks backfire on creative work and that people are really driven by autonomy, mastery and purpose. The core holds. Across 128 experiments, expected tangible rewards reduced people's interest in a task for its own sake once the reward stopped (d = −.28 to −.40; Deci, Koestner & Ryan 1999) ~85 %. Children who expected a "Good Player" award for drawing drew less afterwards than children who got the same award unexpectedly (Lepper, Greene & Nisbett 1973). Rewards can also change what a behaviour means: when Israeli daycares fined parents for late pickup, lateness went up and stayed up after the fine was removed (Gneezy & Rustichini 2000) ~70 %. The fine had become a price.

The headline claim, that rewards make people worse at creative work, is where the book overreaches ~15 %. Its showcase, the candle problem, found that offering money slowed people down on a puzzle that needs insight (Glucksberg 1962); a 2013 replication found no negative effect (Ramm, Tjøtta & Torsvik 2013). A later meta-analysis found incentives helped on interesting tasks about as much as on dull ones (δ ≈ .58 against .52), though less for quality (Kim, Gerhart & Fang 2022). The better summary is "both": across 183 studies, intrinsic motivation predicted the quality of work, incentives predicted quantity, and the two worked at the same time (Cerasoli, Nicklin & Ford 2014) ~70 %. Pink is directionally right and about one size too strong.

Cal Newport's So Good They Can't Ignore You asks where the love of the work comes from. He argues that "follow your passion" is bad advice, because most people don't have a passion that maps onto a job. Of 539 Québec college students, 84% had an activity they felt passionate about, but only 3.6% of those activities had to do with work or study; about 60% were sports (Vallerand et al. 2003). Interests also seem to grow rather than wait to be found: in short studies, mostly with students, those who believed interests are fixed lost interest faster when a new topic got hard (O'Keefe, Dweck & Walton 2018) ~70 %.

The strong version, that following your passion is the worse strategy, isn't supported. People who look for a fit and people who expect to develop their passion end up with similar passion, satisfaction and income, by different routes (Chen, Ellsworth & Schwarz 2015) ~30 %. Newport's alternative, building rare and valuable skill, belongs to Leverage.

Choosing what to neglect

The last decision is the least comfortable. An average life lasts about 4,000 weeks, roughly 77 years. That's arithmetic, and its consequence is logic: every yes is a no to everything else that could have filled the same hours. Oliver Burkeman's Four Thousand Weeks argues that the skill isn't doing more but choosing well what to fail at (Burkeman 2021). His claim that efficiency mostly brings more work, the way a new road fills with traffic, is plausible but untested.

Drucker had a word for the practical side: posteriorities. Choosing priorities is easy; deciding what to stop doing is harder and matters more. His test is to ask of every activity, "What would happen if this were not done at all?", and drop whatever gets the answer "nothing" (Drucker 1967) (~70%). That rating rests on a mechanism, not a test of the question: fewer commitments in parallel means each finishes sooner (see Flow). The popular version, Warren Buffett's "two lists" of 25 goals with 20 to avoid at all costs, comes second-hand from his pilot and was never confirmed by Buffett. The idea doesn't need him.

Like the cafeteria shelves, a list of commitments is stocked long before anyone stands in front of it. Most productivity advice is about getting through the list faster. This station is about what goes on it.

What doesn't work

  • "Forget goals, build systems." Specific, hard goals beat "do your best" by d = .42–.80 across more than 100 tasks (Locke & Latham 2002). The book's claim: ~30%.
  • "Rewards kill creativity." The candle problem didn't replicate, and incentives help on interesting tasks too (Ramm et al. 2013; Kim et al. 2022) ~15 %.
  • "I procrastinate because I'm a perfectionist." Across 691 correlations, the link is about zero (r = −.03); unpleasant tasks and impulsiveness matter far more (Steel 2007). Steel's pattern: ~85 %.
  • "Mental contrasting rewires you unconsciously." A new-data replication found no difference from the control condition (Kappes et al. 2012). ~15%.
  • "Sleep on it and your unconscious will decide better." The unconscious-thought effect failed a 2015 meta-analysis and replication (Nieuwenstein et al. 2015) ~15 %. A plain pause before a hot decision still helps (~70%).

Try this

  • Turn "do your best" into a number and a date. If the task is new to you, start with a learning goal instead: "find three ways to…".
  • Run a five-minute WOOP for the week's most important task. Name the inner obstacle, then write the plan in strict form: "If [obstacle], then I will [action]." Rehearse it once.
  • Move the shelves. For one habit, put the good option within reach and add a step to the bad one. Expect weeks to months, not days, and don't treat a missed day as a reset.
  • Write down a rule for one recurring decision, such as which requests you accept or how you score candidates. Before any large project, hold a premortem.
  • Once a quarter, list every commitment and ask Drucker's question: what would happen if this were not done at all? Drop at least one.

17 claims checked

The evidence behind this article

Every claim above, rated by the chance it holds up against the research. Open one for the sources and their exact words.

  1. Burkeman (2021). Four Thousand Weeks · Book
  2. Cerasoli, Nicklin, Ford (2014). Intrinsic motivation and extrinsic incentives jointly predict performance: A 40-year meta-analysis. · Meta-analysis
  3. Chen, Ellsworth, Schwarz (2015). Finding a Fit or Developing It · Study
  4. Clear (2018). Atomic Habits · Book
  5. Deci, Koestner, Ryan (1999). A meta-analytic review of experiments examining the effects of extrinsic rewards on intrinsic motivation. · Meta-analysis
  6. Drucker (1963). Managing for Business Effectiveness · Source
  7. Drucker (1967). The Effective Executive · Book
  8. Glucksberg (1962). The influence of strength of drive on functional fixedness and perceptual recognition · Study
  9. Gneezy, Rustichini (2000). A Fine is a Price · Study
  10. Gollwitzer, Sheeran (2006). Implementation intentions and goal achievement: A meta-analysis of effects and processes · Meta-analysis
  11. Grove, Zald, Lebow, Snitz, Nelson (2000). Clinical versus mechanical prediction: A meta-analysis. · Meta-analysis
  12. Hofmann, Baumeister, Förster, Vohs (2012). Everyday temptations: An experience sampling study of desire, conflict, and self-control · Study
  13. Kanfer, Ackerman (1989). Motivation and cognitive abilities: An integrative/aptitude-treatment interaction approach to skill acquisition · Study
  14. Kappes, Singmann, Oettingen (2012). Mental contrasting instigates goal pursuit by linking obstacles of reality with instrumental behavior · Study
  15. Kim, Gerhart, Fang (2022). Do financial incentives help or harm performance in interesting tasks? · Meta-analysis
  16. Kirgios, Mandel, Park, Milkman, Gromet, Kay, Duckworth (2020). Teaching temptation bundling to boost exercise: A field experiment · Study
  17. Lally, van Jaarsveld, Potts, Wardle (2009). How are habits formed: Modelling habit formation in the real world · Study
  18. Lepper, Greene, Nisbett (1973). Undermining children's intrinsic interest with extrinsic reward: A test of the "overjustification" hypothesis · Study
  19. Locke, Latham (2002). Building a practically useful theory of goal setting and task motivation: A 35-year odyssey · Source
  20. Milkman, Minson, Volpp (2014). Holding the Hunger Games Hostage at the Gym: An Evaluation of Temptation Bundling · Study
  21. Mitchell, Russo, Pennington (1989). Back to the future: Temporal perspective in the explanation of events · Study
  22. Newport (2012). So Good They Can't Ignore You · Book
  23. Nieuwenstein, Wierenga, Morey, Wicherts, Blom, Wagenmakers, van Rijn (2015). On making the right choice: A meta-analysis and large-scale replication attempt of the unconscious thought advantage · Meta-analysis
  24. O’Keefe, Dweck, Walton (2018). Implicit Theories of Interest: Finding Your Passion or Developing It? · Study
  25. Oettingen (2014). Rethinking Positive Thinking · Book
  26. Oettingen, Mayer (2002). The motivating function of thinking about the future: Expectations versus fantasies. · Study
  27. Pink (2009). Drive · Book
  28. Ramm, Tjotta, Torsvik (2013). Incentives and Creativity in Groups · Study
  29. Sackett, Zhang, Berry, Lievens (2022). Revisiting meta-analytic estimates of validity in personnel selection: Addressing systematic overcorrection for restriction of range. · Meta-analysis
  30. Sheeran, Listrom, Gollwitzer (2024). The when and how of planning: Meta-analysis of the scope and components of implementation intentions in 642 tests · Meta-analysis
  31. Steel (2007). The nature of procrastination: A meta-analytic and theoretical review of quintessential self-regulatory failure. · Meta-analysis
  32. Thorndike, Riis, Sonnenberg, Levy (2014). Traffic-light labels and choice architecture: Promoting healthy food choices · Study
  33. Thorndike, Sonnenberg, Riis, Barraclough, Levy (2012). A 2-Phase Labeling and Choice Architecture Intervention to Improve Healthy Food and Beverage Choices · Study
  34. Vallerand et al. (2003). Les passions de l'âme: On obsessive and harmonious passion · Study
  35. Wang, Wang, Gai (2021). A Meta-Analysis of the Effects of Mental Contrasting With Implementation Intentions on Goal Attainment · Meta-analysis
  36. Winters, Latham (1996). The Effect of Learning versus Outcome Goals on a Simple versus a Complex Task · Study
  37. Wood, Mento, Locke (1987). Task complexity as a moderator of goal effects: A meta-analysis · Meta-analysis

Share

XLinkedIn